Even though this group is short on male contributors (and therefore readers), I wanted to share this piece–sort of as a public service.
Please remember my previous disclaimer. I love women. Love, love, love them. They are wiser, more beautiful, more loving, and more compassionate than men are. I have many more female friends than I have male friends. So, I hope you will still be talking to me after reading this. Or even better—leave a comment and tell me if, how, and/or why I am wrong. I will offer you my sincerest apology.
But, I’m not wrong. Not about this.
There will be times, many times if your relationship is long-term, when your female partner will come to you needing to talk. She will come to you with a problem about her friends, her work, the next-door neighbor who annoys her, her physical or mental health.
She will be distressed and clearly in need of your compassionate attention, and as a good friend and partner, you will listen patiently, occasionally uttering sympathetic noises (they don’t have to be actual words), indicating that you really care about her dilemma and that she has every reason to feel as though the world is ending and that she is currently, at this moment, the most justifiably unhappy person in the world.
Once she has exhausted herself, she may then look at you expectantly. And now, you must be very, very careful, my friend.
As men, we like to fix things. We are hard-wired to it and conditioned by our society to assess a problem and come up with a solution. If you have been smart enough simply to listen and let her talk uninterrupted, congratulations. But while you’ve been waiting for her to finish, undoubtedly you’ve been thinking about how to fix her problem, thinking about her best course of action. Her solution, you think, is painfully obvious to you.
If you are smart, rather than suggesting any practical solutions, your best play here is to shut the fuck up.
Why? Why not help her with her problem and “fix” it like you would a dripping faucet or squeaky door? After all, she wouldn’t be sharing all of this if she didn’t want your input, right?
Wrong. Dead wrong. Your solutions are the last thing she wants right now. Why? Because she already knows the solution, already knows what she has to do next. Remember, she is smarter than you.
You look confused. This is normal. Try to get used to that feeling. Embrace it.
All she wants from you right now is for you to empathize with her, to agree with her. In a pinch, you can even repeat things she just said to you with added emphasis to show that you were listening, that you understand, that you care.
In fact, as spontaneous and anguished as her recital may have been, you may be the third or fourth person with whom she has had this exact same rant. She most likely has approached her girlfriends first, and they’ve already sliced, diced, and dissected this problem over wine, chocolates, and ice cream. They will have tried to sooth your partner with affirmations and oddly communicative woman noises that we (males) cannot duplicate or understand, and they have supplied her with the kind of comfort that only calories and alcohol can bring.
Even knowing this, you will have to battle your impulse to help her slap a patch on the problem. If you find yourself start to say something like, “Well, you know, you could…” or “It seems to me like the best thing to do…” or even worse, “Well, if I were in your place, I’d certainly…” put both hands around your throat and squeeze until you are unable to speak.
Make all of your responses as non-specific as possible. Remember, she’s hurt, unhappy, and angry. Take some comfort that it is not because of something you have done. “That’s terrible,” “I can’t believe this,” “You have every right to be upset,” are all appropriate. You can use any of these more than once because it doesn’t matter what you say. What matters is that she thinks you are listening, that you are concerned.
Finally, she may even articulate what she feels is the solution to her problem and what she plans to do. Your job is to agree enthusiastically. Maybe now it’s time to put your arm around her, offer her a glass of wine, take her out to dinner. After all, she’s been sorely wronged by life, and she sought you out to be her person of the moment. You are one lucky guy. Just try to keep your mouth shut.
6 thoughts on “Men: Why It’s Important To Keep Your Mouth Shut”
So True! I loved the “sliced, diced and dissected” and “oddly communicative woman noises!” Marc and I found that similar advice in Men are from Mars; Women are from Venus made a huge difference for us! Thanks for this social service!
Thanks, Cathy. I’m glad you liked this one. I had fun writing it! I just worried that I’d be the only one that thought it was funny!
That’s weird… I was under the impression that “long-term relationship” and “talking” we’re mutually exclusive things. I don’t know how my relationship could have survived so long if we talked… I mean apart from the usual directives like, “Honey, I can’t see the TV when you clean the coffee table… Could you get me a beer instead, maybe clean it later.”
P., as usual, you are totally right. I am in a long-term relationship and the most important conversations seem to be centered around the remote control, paint colors (shudder!!!), and who’s driving to dinner tonight
Pingback: “Retired, Not Dead” Turns 100! My Ten Favorite Posts: A Retrospective | Retired, Not Dead